Pit bulls are still banned in towns around Kansas City. These dog lovers are fighting for a repeal | KCUR

Pit bulls are still banned in towns around Kansas City. These dog lovers are fighting for a repeal | KCUR

Cindy Marshall utilized to wander her pet, Nitro, in her Lee’s Summit subdivision every single working day. Marshall lives near the town’s border with Independence and says Nitro loved collecting feathers along the way.

But as they approached Independence town restrictions, Marshall and Nitro would transform about and head back residence.

“We would stroll all over a person of the lakes in our subdivision and we get a great deal of turkeys here, and of program turkeys eliminate their feathers and he would uncover a feather, decide it up, and we would do a 180 and go back property,” Marshall says.

Independence prohibits people from proudly owning, transporting, or “exercising manage over” pit bulls inside of city restrictions. Penalties vary from fines up to $500 or jail time. It’s 1 of few towns in the Kansas Metropolis metro that nonetheless ban the breeds — together with Leawood, Kansas, and Kearney, Missouri.

Lately, Independence citizens have started out a petition to eradicate the ban. Close to 30 activists, which includes Marshall, will work to accumulate 3,500 signatures to drive a citywide vote in Independence’s upcoming election.

‘Arbitrary’ and ineffective

Independence defines a pit bull as “any canine that is an American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier, or any pet exhibiting the bulk of physical qualities of any a person or far more of the higher than breeds.”

Marshall claims that language is extremely wide.

“I assume it should really be eradicated since it is arbitrary and it is really subjective,” Marshall said.


Cindy Marshall’s doggy, Nitro, lays down on a mattress.

In accordance to the American Veterinary Clinical Affiliation (AVMA), breed-distinct bans discriminate against responsible pet dog entrepreneurs and do not tackle the situation of irresponsible ownership. The association also suggests bans can be hard to enforce with blended breed canines.

Independence resident Glenda Bailey began amassing signatures for the ballot evaluate on Tuesday at election polling stations.

“Breed distinct laws targets a unique breed. In this scenario, any dog that displays the the vast majority of actual physical features with pit bull type canine, but no dog breed is intense,” Bailey stated. “There are aggressive puppies in all breeds, but not 1 breed is all aggressive.”

An particularly common breed

Pit bulls at the time experienced a track record for staying affiliated with dogfighting, but most are pretty affectionate. Marshall made use of to volunteer at Independence Animal Products and services and regularly introduced pit bulls to her household for a go to.

She said they beloved to snuggle and be near to humans. But even among pit bulls, personalities can fluctuate. Marshall’s puppy Nitro, who died of cancer ideal just before Xmas final yr, wasn’t like the normal pit bull.

“He was pretty reserved, variety of kept to himself,” Marshall stated. “He constantly wanted to be up on the mattress with me, but he was not one particular that required to snuggle.”

Independence Animal Companies director Christina Heinen suggests that about 20{95b18eb6fc4f42efd0d92738dfc3fb79fde21da267a711ecdf0381147c27bb86} of the dogs they choose in are pit bull breeds. And pit bulls really don’t have significantly issue finding adopted, possibly — even if Independence citizens cannot individual a single on their own.

“When we run the numbers for the length of keep for pit bulls right here at our shelter, it is really pretty equivalent to the size of remain for any medium or substantial breed pet,” Heinen states. “For 2022, the length of keep for pit bull breeds was 26.95 days. For all medium and large breed puppies, it was, I think, 25.5 days.”

KC Pet Undertaking, the most significant animal shelter in the point out of Missouri, fully supports taking away the pit bull ban in Independence.

“About 22{95b18eb6fc4f42efd0d92738dfc3fb79fde21da267a711ecdf0381147c27bb86} of the pet dogs that appear into our shelter are pit bull variety canine that could be labeled as pit bulls in Independence,” says spokesperson Tori Fugate. “And so this would just make a substantial affect for the pet dogs that are in our treatment at this shelter.”

A craze in opposition to pit bull bans

In this June 28, 2013 photo, Apollo, a Blue Nose pit bull is shown in Madison, Miss.

Rogelio V. Solis


Associated Push

In this June 28, 2013 photo, Apollo, a Blue Nose pit bull is revealed in Madison, Miss.

Close to Kansas Metropolis, some municipalities experienced pit bull bans on the guides for a long time. But Independence only handed its regulation soon after a handful of highly-publicized pit bull attacks in 2006.

In Kansas City, Missouri, a pit bull killed a 71-12 months-aged girl following it jumped a neighbor’s fence, and an Independence person was practically mauled to loss of life by a few pit bulls the similar 12 months.

Above the very last 5 several years, several area governments have taken off breed-distinct bans from their metropolis and county charters.

Wyandotte County instituted a pit bull ban in 1990 that threatened violators with jail sentences of up to 90 days or a high-quality of up to $1,000. Leaders repealed it in 2019.

Overland Park, Liberty, and Excelsior Springs have also repealed their bans in the latest years. A monthly bill released in the Missouri Property of Reps this session would protect against metropolitan areas from regulating canines by breed.

To get on the Independence ballot, Bailey claimed they will need 5{95b18eb6fc4f42efd0d92738dfc3fb79fde21da267a711ecdf0381147c27bb86} of registered voters to indicator the petition, which is just beneath 3,200 signatures. The group is aiming for 3,500 as a safeguard, in scenario there are any concerns with the town audit.

“We have 30 days to acquire what we need to have and the petition then will go again to the metropolis and they will rely and validate that all the citizens who have signed are registered people,” Bailey claims.

Bailey states it’s time for Independence to embrace pit bulls yet again.

“The shelters are overflowing with them,” she claims. “And it commenced because this laws was implemented pretty substantially all over the place for these a very long period of time.”